Prenups in Wisconsin: Why a “Keep It Separate” Clause Isn’t Enough in a Marital Property State

Close-up of a clenched fist with a blurred background of a woman comforting a child on a sofa.

Getting married means building a life together, but that doesn’t mean combining every financial asset. You may be bringing a home, savings, a business, or an inheritance into the marriage that you want to keep separate. A prenuptial agreement can help set those boundaries and protect your financial interests.

However, if you’re getting married, you need the right documentation to make sure each person keeps their own property. When it comes to prenups in Wisconsin, a “keep it separate” clause isn’t enough in a marital property state.

What Is Wisconsin’s Marital Property Law?

Wisconsin has a marital property system under Chapter 766 of the Wisconsin Statutes. That means property acquired during marriage is presumed to be marital property, no matter which spouse earned the money or whose name appears on the account or title.

However, Wisconsin law does recognize certain exceptions. For example, property owned before marriage and certain gifts or inheritances one spouse receives may qualify as individual property.

With a prenuptial agreement, you can help set how property will be classified and managed. But you need to choose your words carefully and work with a reputable family law attorney. 

A “keep it separate” clause identifies certain assets as belonging to one spouse instead of becoming marital property. While this may sound simple, Wisconsin’s marital property laws can make things more complicated, especially once those assets generate income, increase in value, or become mixed with marital funds.

Mixing Separate and Marital Money

One of the biggest issues for couples is commingling. This happens when individually owned money or property becomes mixed with marital assets.

Let’s say you have $150,000 in savings when you get married. Your prenuptial agreement sets aside that money as your individual property. But a few years later, you begin depositing your paycheck into the same account. You and your spouse also use the account to pay household bills and cover other shared expenses.

Now, it may become difficult to determine which funds originally belonged to you and which were acquired during the marriage.

Keep in mind that doesn’t mean your original savings automatically become marital property. Wisconsin law allows individuals to use tracing to establish the individual character of certain assets, even when they’ve been mixed with marital property. However, you will need those financial records to show where the money came from and how it was handled.

With a well-written prenuptial agreement, you can anticipate these situations. This document can set expectations for what happens when separate funds are deposited into joint accounts, used for shared expenses, or combined with marital earnings.

What Should You Include in a Wisconsin Prenup?

A prenuptial agreement should reflect your actual financial situation and take into consideration how those circumstances could change. Your agreement may need to address:

  • Existing assets and debts: Identify what each person owns and owes before marriage.
  • Future income: Establish how earnings, investment returns, rental income, and other sources of income will be treated.
  • Business interests: Address ownership, future growth, income, and contributions made during the marriage.
  • Real estate: Clarify how properties, mortgage payments, renovations, and value increases will be handled.
  • Gifts and inheritances: Establish expectations for assets received individually during the marriage.
  • Joint purchases: Explain how property purchased together will be classified and managed.

Both parties should also have a full understanding of each other’s financial circumstances before signing. Full financial disclosure, adequate time to review the agreement, and the opportunity to consult with your lawyer can help reduce the potential for disagreements down the road.

This is the time to work with an experienced Waukesha family law attorney. They can help you create an agreement that reflects your intentions and addresses the financial realities of married life.

Hand holding wooden puzzle piece with handshake icon between male and female avatar puzzle pieces.

Think Beyond the Wedding Day

Prenups in Wisconsin give you an opportunity to protect your assets. However, you want clear language. A “keep it separate” clause might seem like the best solution, but you want to account for everything that may occur during your marriage.

At the Law Offices of Mark S. Knutson, we can help with these first big legal decisions as a couple. If you’re considering a prenuptial agreement in Wisconsin, we can help protect your interests and your options as you begin this next chapter. Schedule a consultation today.

This blog post is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice